MMUUS ARCHIVE MATERIALS AT S.U. BIRD LIBRARY

 

First batch, August 3, 1995. 5 boxes, Transmitted 7/95

 

BOX 1 (numbers indicate folders)

 

1. Scrapbook. Dudley P. Phelps. 1838-1873

2. Book. Biographies, SERVICE RECORD of members WWI. 8/2/25.

3. Register of soldiers. ST. JAMES ARMY CLUB 6/9/19-10/25/17

4. Scrapbook. Amos Padgham, 1880 - 1905.

5. Nine colored slides. Stained glass windows, James St. bldg.

6. Printer's woodcut: Interior of James St. church as built with organ behind pulpit.

7. Photo cut. John Haines Holmes

8. Photo cut. Interior of James St. church after organ was moved to back of sanctuary.

9. Vitaplate. James St. church exterior.

10. Large illustrated Bible with presentation letter to S.J. May from friends. Covers not attached.

 

BOX 2

 

Secretaries' minutes of society meetings. Nine books

 

1. March 11, 1845 - Feb. 8, 1890 - (shifted to Box 1)

2. Feb. 1890 - May 1919

3. July 1, 1919 - Dec. 18, 1932

4. Feb. 8, 1932 - May 10, 1936

5. June 1, 1936 - May 11, 1948

6. June 4, 1948 - Mar. 4, 1958

7. April 1, 1958 - June 7, 1963

8. Sept. 4, 1963 - June 3, 1970

9. June 9, 1970 - Mar. II, 1980

 

BOXES 3, 4, & 5

 

27 Scrapbooks containing mostly newspaper clippings and also photographs and other memorabilia. Listed under ministers.

 

1. Concerning S. J. May, 1844-1868

2. Calthrop Era:

1868-1911

1885-1903

1909-1917

3. Applebee: 1910-1935

4. Argow:

1930-1936

1936-1937

1930-1941

5. Romig:

1942-1945 presented by E. Rosebrugh

April 1941-June 1948 also Canfield

1941-1946

Sept 1942-June 1946

6. Canfield:

1946-1951

June 1948-Dec 1953

7. Zoerheide:

1951-1961 also Canfield

Jan 1954-Dec 1955

Jan 1956-Dec 1959

Jan 1960-Dec 1962 also Fuller

8. Fuller:

1962-1967

Jan 1963-Dec 1964

1964-1972

Jan 1965-Nov 1966

Dec 1966-0ct 1968

1967-1972

1972-1973

Sept 1973-Aug 1974

1973-1974

 

Second batch, Transmitted 1998

 

Box 1

 

John Storer. Minister 1839-1844

1.      Two copies of letter from church members. 1844

2.      Portrait of John Storer, undated

3.      Text of memorial plaque, undated

4.      Xerox copies of archival material gathered by J. Hoefer and I. Baros-Johnson at On. Hist. Soc., UUA and Harvard libraries

5.      Miscellaneous: Typed Statements: Origin of the church, covenant of the Unitarian Congregational Church of Syracuse, Onondaga County Record of meeting to start Unitarian Congregational Society in Syracuse. Longhand: Signers of Covenant, 5-page history of Society through SJ May ministry. Copy of .invitation to Trenton (NY) Church and delegates to installation of John Storer, 1839. (Note from 1866 on funeral of Deacon Peter Vanderkamp.)

6.      Diagram of Pews, Church of Messiah 1843. Record of pew sale, Nov. 24, 1843, 12 "deeds."

7.      Letter and request to John Townsend for lot to erect a church. 1840.

8.      Legal papers re building Church of the Messiah, 1843, 1844.

9.      Consecration of the Church of the Messiah--Program, copy typed from Christian Register Dec. 9, 1843: Account of Dedication of the Church of the Messiah".

10. Postcard from Margaret T. Smith re death and burial of John Storer.

11. Portrait Amelia Bradbury, typed quote from Chase history about her and her school. Four-page historical essay about Syracuse in 1830s and 1840s.

12. House of worship subscribers 1838-1841. Mr. Storer's salary subscribers 1839-1842. Sums obtained by Mr. Storer. dated 1845.

13. Newspaper "New York Christian Messenger" 3 copies, 1841-1843

 

Samuel Joseph May, Minister 1845-1868

1.      Book of Church Records presented by JPB Storer, leather bound inscribed Alfred Wilkinson, May 1, 1870 Begun by JPBS and continued by SJM. Contains 1838 covenant, membership and marriage records.

2.      Bound Book contains Incorporation of Unitarian Congregational Society in Syracuse, October 4, 1838, recorded by County Clerk Jan. 2, 1839; records of trustee meetings; list of members

3.      Bound book inscribed Alfred Wilkinson, May 1, 1870 inside front cover (detached). Record of organizing meeting and covenant; list of names with dates through 1844

4.      Photographs of SJM: (a) Original 8 1/2 x 11 1/2. (b) 2 copies 8 x 10 by Charles White of large picture in roller. (c) Copy 5 x 7 SJM and George Emerson. (d) 3 copies: SJM and bridal couple, Post Standard Feb. 13, 1944

5.      SJM correspondence: 17 letters to and from SJM dated over years from 1844 when called to Syracuse up to 1868. Terms of employment, loans. Some originals, some copies

6.      2Photocopies SJM letters, Nov. 14, 1857 and undated. 2 Typed copies SJM to trustees 1863. 2 typed copies SJM to Friends, 1856. written memo re number of hours, minutes, L.T. May 1854. List of books, George E. May

7.      Written draft statement SJM mission, 1852

8.      4 miscellaneous clippings

9.      Bound book: Recollections of the Antislavery Conflict by SJM

10. Xerox copies OHA clippings 1850-1865

11. 10-page typed copy Syracuse Daily Journal, 1846, First annual meeting of Syracuse Orphan Asylum

12. Articles and correspondence re busts of SJM at Onondaga Historical Assoc. (OHA) and MMUUS

13. Leather notebook listing subscriptions for annuity for SJM. Oct. 11, 1867. Copies of letters re SJM annuity and hiring S R Calthrop

14. Text of marble plaque installed in wall of James St. church. Cemetery map (1990) site of SJM grave.

15. 100th anniversary of SJM birthday: Program, description of program, copy of prayer, undated

16. Three copies biography of SJM by Joseph May. From "Heralds of a Liberal Faith Vol III, AUA 1915. 2 Mimeographed pamphlets, one Xerox copy.

17. Heretic in Syracuse: Samuel Joseph May 1845 - 1873 by Catherine Covert Stepanek. PhD thesis. 2 copies.

18. Notes, talks and sermons re SJM, typed copies

19. Written notes (John C. Fuller handwriting?) for 111th Jerry Rescue celebration?

20. Cornell Library Journal 1967 article about SJM by Pease and Pease, "Samuel May: Civil Libertarian."

21. 5 sermons by Joseph May, 2 Xerox copies of one of them. Xerox copy of title page Discourse to Cambridge Theological School Graduating Class, SJM 1847

22. Syracuse Village and City by Carroll E. Smith and Margaret Tredwell Smith. OHA 1897

23. Life of Samuel J. May by George Emerson, Samuel May and Thomas J. Mumford. 2 bound books.

24. SJM letter to Harriet Martineau 1853

25. In Memoriam. Samuel Joseph May, 2 paperbound copies, 1871. Samuel Joseph May: a Memorial Study by Joseph May 1898. 2 paperbound copies

26. The Tailor Boy no author 1865. Inscribed SJM 1864. Rocks and Shoals: Lectures to Young Men by George E Hopkins 1870. Inscribed SJM 1870

27. Letter remembrance of SJM by AF Pease to E. Lewis 1928. Xerox copy and typed copy of same

28. Photo Rev. Luther Lee. List 4 sources SJM history

29. List of Church members, 1845

30. Church of Messiah pew diagrams, 1853; before 1867. Lists of pew holders, 1850 - 1863, some undated. Pew contracts 1849 ++; receipts 1864-1865

31. Original Incorporation Certificate Mar 12, 1845, and 2 typed copies

32. Order of Service Dedication of Church of Messiah, 1853--2 copies

33. Lists of pledges for debt, building, salary

34. Accounts, receipts, pledges, 1848 - 1849. Notice of congregational meeting to hire SJM 1845. Notice of conveyance of land 1848. Quit claim signed by members 1868

35. Letter 1844- Ellsworth Phelps- new organ Letter 1852- Holbrook, receipt for use of bell. Two letters 1852- B.D. Simmons new organ proposed and ordered. 2 letters 1853 from John May re Simmons progress on organ. Letter 1853 C.D. Kellog Cobb-organ for sale

36. Committee report: Plan for "General Committee" of Church of the Messiah. List of 21 men, untitled, undated

37. Letter 1852-Trustees to JG Northrup to repair and pay for damages to house and property

38. Pew releases and subscriptions to finance rebuilding. 1852. Mar 12, 1845 Reorganization of U. Congo Society. Registration recorded in village records

39. "Boston Investigator" Wed. Sept 19, 1855. 4-page weekly newspaper for free thinkers

40. Note on supply minister Rev. Joseph Angier, 1859

41. "What Do Unitarians Believe?" Samuel J. May. American Unitarian Association, Boston, MA, no date

 

Samuel R. Calthrop 1868-1911

1.      Five photographs of Calthrop home Primrose Hill

2.      Seven Photographs: Annie Agan (later Mrs. Franklin Chase), Mrs. R. G. Stone, Bronson Alcott, Mary E. Bagg (Mrs. James L. Bagg), W. B. Cogswell, Mary Gormer White, Frederick Rowland Hazard and Mrs. Dora Gannett Sedgwick Hazard (1880)

3.      Twenty-six photographs: 14 SRC; SRC with two women; John Calthrop brother of SRC; 4 prints together: MMU church, Mrs. Elizabeth Primrose Calthrop, SRC reading, Primfose Hill with SRC on porch; Richard G. Calthrop (son SRC); Large print Mrs. EPC; Elizabeth Calthrop daughter SRC; Henry Cooper reading; Cooper family picnic 1904; MMU church Sunday School, 1897

4.      Photo copies of portraits: 1 of SJM and 2 of SRC

5.      Cassette tape, 7/23/1983 Mary Cooper remembers SRC Transcript of interview, William McLennan" "7/27/1983

6.      SRC letter April (no year) accepting call to Syracuse. Typed copy of report on SRC installation. Typed copy of "Liberal Christian"-SRC asked to stay in Syracuse 2/24/1872. Typed copy of "Syracuse Journal" Aug 8, 1870. Typed copy "The First Grapes" – Amos Padgham

1.      Letters: 2/8/72 to call SRC to Detroit. 6/4/75 Roxbury, MA offers presidency of Antioch College. 3/16/96 from Richard S. (Webster?) nephew re "Venezuelan Blue Book" and British Case. 10/7/1899-GB Spaulding invites SRC to 75th Anniversary of first Presbyterian church. 2/5/1906, 11/14/06, 2/12/07 Letters from Andrew D. White of Cornell to SRC. 11/7/1915 letter from JA Brashear, Ed. Fund Commission re "The Supreme Reality," SRC book with letter from Rabbi Levy enclosed Nov. 19, 1915

2.      Thirty-fifth anniversary of SRC installation 1903: 3 programs, 2 soft-cover booklets and one hardcover book of speeches at installation service. 3 Benediction Cards

3.      Two paperbound books: Notes on the Families of Calthorpe and Calthrop, includes slip with author's name; copy of "Heirs of John H. Calthrop: Part III: "The Lincolnshire Calthrops."

4.      Photocopy of a page of The Weekly Recorder Nov 22, 188? The Craftsman magazine 10/1905 contains SRC article

5.      Messenger Boy's Christmas Greeting card with verse by SRC from former boys club member

 

Box 2

 

6.      Diagram of streamlined train from Patent #49227. Article by Edith Calthrop Bump, "The Life of Samuel Robert Calthrop" with rejection slip from Reader's Digest 1947

7.      Handwritten articles by Helen Collins Megrew: "Dr. Samuel Calthrop, Onondaga Creek, Earlier Syracuse." Undated

8.      slide photo SRC bust. Card from Mrs. Tracy re SRC bust. Page from D. Ashley re SRC bust. Page from Helen Hiscock Eager re chimes and renovations, James St. church

9.      Three reprints of "Recollections of the Old Master", Harvard Graduates Magazine, 3. 1923

10. Poems paperbound by Edith Calthrop Bump and" To My Father" by same

11. Typescript and 2 carbons resolution of MMUS trustees re death of SRC. Envelope for George N. Cheney. Two typed statements 1/9/1899 from church members with historical information

12. Clip from MMUS newsletter "Our Wider Ministry" Space-time saying SRC wrote on cardboard. 3 copies. SRC essay "A Day's Life" mounted on cardboard; Two sayings lettered on cardboard; Cardboard and ribbon-bound poetry by SRC, portrait on front cover, photo Primrose Hill on back

13. The Heaven of the Moon, 2 hardbound copies. Printed folder Birthday Tribute to Ernst Held... 6/28/1900. Cardboard and ribbon bound typed "The Heaven of the Moon". 3 printed copies "Summer Evening and Night on the Lake" and a 4th copy mounted on cardboard with SRC portrait

14. Four-page essay by SRC "Sunspots and Weather", typed. Ms. "The Doleful story-of the Cats and the Clover." Notes of SRC sermon "Let Be Light and Light Was." Ms. and typed copy "The Three Hundred and Sixty-Five Sages: a Tale of Hindustan" by SRC

15. Patent # 49 227 8/8/ 1865 by SRC of Roxbury MA. Note about friends whose sons attended SRC's school

16. Fifteen-page lecture by SRC "The Transvaal, Armenia, and Venezuela," undated

17. Twenty-two Bible lessons by SRC 1890-1892

18. Ring-attached printed sermons and addresses by SRC: 14 delivered at MMU church 1895-1902. 14 delivered elsewhere 1858-1895. Paper-bound copy of sermon "One Lord and His Name On expanded from original sermon, undated

19. Printed booklet "The Primitive Gospel" by SRC, 1892. 13 printed sermons in ring binder 1903-1913

20. Hardcover book "The Liberal Club", Buffalo includes SRC lecture "The Debt which Religion Owes to Science," 1891-1892

21. Book by SRC "God and His World" Boston, GH Ellis Co, 1905

22. Book by SRC "The Supreme Reality", Boston AUA 1913. 28A. Letter from CG Girelius, May 14, 1945 to EC Bump re "The Supreme Reality."

23. Silver dollar and list of other articles in corner stone MHU church laid 8/11/1884. (Opened 10/10/1965 in new building East Genesee St.)

24. Dedication of MMU church: Order of Exercises (1 3/4 copies in very poor condition, 10/20/1885. 30A. Photographs of James St. Church on cardboard and of SRC, both undated

25. Two copies bound record of above dedication (one in poor condition) with historical essay and photographs. Sermon by Joseph May

26. Typed copy "Notes from Secretary's pre 1885 records," (typed in 1960s.) Clipping from Syracuse Herald J. Jan 14, 1946 re church corner Burnet & State Sts. (originally Church of the Messiah) bought from German Lutheran congregation by Italian Catholic congregation

27. Loan application 1871. Mortgage 1871. Bond 1871. Satisfaction of mortgage 1878. Loan application 1872. Envelope Whitman and Barnes mfg. Co.

28. List of unpaid subscriptions 1881

29. Notice of filing of proposed route of NY, W Shore & Buffalo Railway Co, 2 copies. Copy of agreement to sell church property to NYWS&B 1882. Letter from above RR asking to purchase all or part of U Church property 1882. Letter from U. Soc. Committee to RR requesting proposal for purchase of entire property, original and copy, 1882. Letter from RR "negotiate a price" 1882. Resolved:  Committee of MMC empowered to negotiate with RR, undated

30. Pencil copy Warranty Deed James St. property 1884. Pencil copy Church title and search 1881 etc. Sketch of property, undated

31. 1884 list: Church of Messiah trustees, officers, pastor, choir, organist, sexton, building committee, architect

32. Four letters and estimate from Butler and Dial re furnaces, 1885-8. Two letters from Alsop Furnace & Stove Co. 1888. Two letters from J. F. Pease Furnace Co. 1888

33. 1872 form letter to go with subscription card. Also 1876, subscription policy will continue to replace pew rents:. Mailed subscription cards, 1876. December, 1905 treasurer's report May Memorial Sunday school. January 1904: Special appeal for subscriptions

34. 1906 Letter from J.D. Pennock (Mrs. Pass's father) to report on church ventilation. Letter from Clerk A. Padgham to Salem Hyde re implementing church ventilation by committee on repairs. Letter from James Barnes to Salem Hyde re repairs to the ventilation.

35. Folder 41 donated to Onondaga Historical Association, March, 1997

36. Folder 42 donated to Onondaga Historical Association, March, 1997.

37. Undated address book: Members of Unitarian Society of Syracuse. 1883 subscription agreement for site and building, list of names and pledges and subscription list for 1888

38. 1891 congregation list, 1895 church directory including historical sketch, officers, committees, constitution, Women's Alliance, Boy's Evening Home. 1903 church yearbook, 3 copies. Program and menu from banquet honoring Andrew D. White, 1879

39. Two copies of the text of speeches at SJ May Centennial Celebration, Oct. 1898. 1907 church directory

40. List of subscribers undated. List of members undated. 1880-1884 subscribers, pledges, total income and expenses

41. Two pew renter consent forms dated 1897, permission to seat others if pew is unoccupied at time of service. 1884 diagram of pews, annual rent, names of renters. (Recovered from 1884 cornerstone in 1963.) Two copies of 1886 Diagram of pews, annual rent

42. "Miss Ellis' sic Mission" by Mary P. Wells Smith, undated, abridged by Anne E. Howard, Boston. 12-page pamphlet describes Cincinnati woman's outreach via printed word and post office

43. Book given to Church of Messiah by SJM 1868, leather bound record of marriages, 1868 -1878

44. Record of some marriages by SRC 1891-1904 and by WWW Argow 1932-1933. Marriage Record and Certificate, Sept. 1873

45. Orders of Service for ordination of Marie H. Jenney 1898, and Albert W. Clark, 1902

46. 1961 Order of Ordination Service of Estella Elizabeth Padgham, and her Certificate of membership in Unitarian Ministers Association, undated

47. Old and New, Journal of Des Moines Unitarian Church Anniversary 1902 mentions E. Padgham and pictures Marie Jenney, minister

48. Order of Service, Sunday evening, March 5, 1899. Very poor condition, mounted on cardboard

49. Sunday School Annual Reports, 1902-03. 1903-04

50. “The Unitarian Calendar" monthly pub. by AUA for MMUS. Four issues, 1910 and 1911

51. 1903 preliminary program National Conference Unitarian and Other Churches. 20th meeting. (Includes listing of sermon by SRC.)

52. "Hymn and Tune Book: for the church and the home," Boston, AUA, 1871. Theo. L. Poole.

53. "Hymnal: amore Dei," compiled by Mrs. Theodore C. Williams, Boston, George H. Ellis, 1891

54. Two stereoscope photos, AW Padgham in England and a residence on South St. Utica, unidentified people

55. Clip from Herald Journal 11/12/1906: Report of SRC sermon: "Pure Religion Undefiled."